MTG Commander Smiths Podcast

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Is the Spider-Man 🕷️ Superdrop Secret Lair Worth It? 🕸️- #391

Episode 391: 
🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We’re swinging into the Spider-Verse Secret Lair Superdrop! 🕷️💥 Wizards dropped a whole batch of Spidey-themed goodies and we’re breaking down every single drop. Not only are we looking at the art and reprints... but we’re also adding a brand-new feature—grading each drop overall. Don’t worry, the break point numbers are still here, but we’re also giving you our singles price predictions so you know what to grab when peak supply hits.
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/THn6zzMCqWU
 
We’re breaking it all down:🔥 What’s hot🤷‍♂️ What’s meh💰 And which ones are actually worth your cash!
From insane reprints to gorgeous new art, we’re calling out the highlights, talking value, and letting you know which drops are headed straight into our decks.
Wondering if the price hike is justified? We’ve got you. We’re crunching numbers, breaking down Break Points (BP), and helping you decide if this drop’s worth going deep on... or skipping entirely.
👇 Check out what’s in the drop:🔗 Official Superdrop Info🛒 Secret Lair Store
💸 Financial Breakdown (Before Fees/Shipping):
📰 Daily Bugle Breaking News✨ Foil: $70 (BP 4)🔥 Non-Foil: $52 (BP 4)
🦸 Heroic Deeds✨ Foil: $110 (BP 2)🔥 Non-Foil: $90 (BP 2)
🌌 Mana Symbiote (Lands)✨ Foil: $80 – $150+ (BP 1–3)
🕷️ Venom Unleashed (Colors & Inks)✨ Foil: $80 (BP 3)🔥 Non-Foil: $65 (BP 3)
😈 Villainous Plots✨ Foil: $70 (BP 4)🔥 Non-Foil: $60 (BP 3)
 
💡 What’s a Break Point (BP)?BP = How many you need to buy to get one free based on resale value.Buy smart... maybe even flip one to pay for the rest!
💡 What is Break Point (BP)?
Break Point (BP) helps determine how many drops you need to buy to get one essentially free — because let’s be honest, we all want one for the collection!
How it works:1️⃣ Add up the lowest Foil and Non-Foil values.2️⃣ Subtract fees, shipping, and drop cost to find Net Profit.3️⃣ Divide total profit by the cost of one drop to get your BP.
🔍 Example:If a drop costs $40 and has a Net Profit of $80, buying 2 covers the cost of one. (BP 2)If Net Profit is $55, you’d need 4 drops to break even. (BP 4)
💡 Pro Tip: Prices often dip after shipping but tend to recover or even rise 10–16 months later — patience can pay off!
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Magic’s Most Beautiful Art – Our Fav 5 Picks! - #390

🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
🎨 We’re diving into the world of art! We each bring our Fav 5 arts in Magic: The Gathering to the table, highlighting the pieces that stuck with us, blew our minds, or just plain made us say “wow.” From iconic classics to modern masterpieces, we’re celebrating the visuals that make Magic more than just a game... it’s art you can play with.
 
The Commander Smiths talk about their favorite ART of all the cards printed. fav 5 style along with some arts from our childhood in a nostalgic version of favorite arts. also a #StumptheSmithSavant that was way too hard. Enjoy!
 
Adam:
Grove of the Burnwillows https://scryfall.com/card/fut/176/grove-of-the-burnwillows
Three Tree City https://scryfall.com/card/blb/339/three-tree-city
Damnation https://scryfall.com/card/sld/121/damnation
Demonic Tutor https://scryfall.com/card/sta/90/ja/%E6%82%AA%E9%AD%94%E3%81%AE%E6%95%99%E7%A4%BA%E8%80%85-(demonic-tutor)
Sol Ring https://scryfall.com/card/sld/1905/sol-ring
Nostalgia 
B.O.P. https://scryfall.com/card/4ed/234/birds-of-paradise
Tropical Island https://scryfall.com/card/3ed/288/tropical-island
Shivan Dragon https://scryfall.com/card/4ed/220/shivan-dragon
Vesuvan Doppelganger https://scryfall.com/card/3ed/88/vesuvan-doppelganger
Exalted Dragon https://scryfall.com/card/exo/6/exalted-dragon
Lowery
Mystic Remora https://scryfall.com/card/sld/406/mystic-remora
Mother of Runes https://scryfall.com/card/sld/297/mother-of-runes
Killing Wave https://scryfall.com/card/pavr/111/killing-wave
Skullclamp https://scryfall.com/card/sld/1112/skullclamp
Ugin, the Spirit Dragon https://scryfall.com/card/m21/285/ugin-the-spirit-dragon
Nostalgia
Maze of Ith https://scryfall.com/card/drk/117/maze-of-ith
Elves of the Deep Shadow https://scryfall.com/card/drk/76/elves-of-deep-shadow
Gaea's Liege https://scryfall.com/card/3ed/198/gaeas-liege
Hunter's Insight https://scryfall.com/card/m12/180/hunters-insight
Fozen Shade https://scryfall.com/card/3ed/112/frozen-shade
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/kAQ1RjnSXK8
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Hidden Gems in Commander! 💎 Underplayed Cards You NEED to Try! - #389

🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We’re shining a light on the hidden gems of Commander — the underused and underplayed cards that deserve way more love than they get. 💎 Sometimes the strongest tech flies under the radar, and we’re pulling together a list of cards that could make a huge impact in your decks but rarely see the table. Expect a mix of spicy utility, clever synergies, and a few “wait… why doesn’t anyone play this?!” moments.
 
The Commander Smiths want to talk about some cards they feel should be played more along with a #StumptheSmithSavant that Adam literally can't read. Enjoy!
 
Underplayed Cards
Adam: 
Urza's Saga
Dense Foliage https://scryfall.com/card/6ed/221/dense-foliage
Rammas Echor, Ancient Shield https://scryfall.com/card/ltc/505/rammas-echor-ancient-shield
Bria, Riptide Rogue https://scryfall.com/card/blb/379/bria-riptide-rogue
Psychotic Fury https://scryfall.com/card/dis/68/psychotic-fury
Lifeline https://scryfall.com/card/usg/299/lifeline
Lowery:
Walking Archive https://scryfall.com/card/dis/169/walking-archive
Gretchen Tillowitch https://scryfall.com/card/afr/223/gretchen-titchwillow
Squee's Embrace https://scryfall.com/card/apc/122/squees-embrace
Meria, Scholar of Antiquity https://scryfall.com/card/dmu/206/meria-scholar-of-antiquity
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/4_jW0hReE6Y
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Stop Playing THESE Cards! The Most Overused Cards in Commander! - #388

🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We’re tackling one of the spiciest topics in Commander… the most overused cards in the format. 💥 You know the ones — the staples that show up in almost every deck. But are they really must-plays... or are we just leaning on them out of habit?
We’re breaking down which cards we think are everywhere, why they’re so popular, and when you might want to skip them for something more fun (or more powerful 👀). Expect hot takes, laughs, and maybe a few shots fired at some “sacred cows” of EDH 😂🔥
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/xfRoKsD0oKU
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Reserved List Reprints? Here’s What We’d Choose! #387

Episode 387: 
🎙 This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙
This week we’re going deep into Magic’s most infamous vault — the Reserved List. 💎 We’re talking about which cards we wish could be reprinted, why they deserve another shot at seeing play, and what changes it could bring to Commander and the wider MTG community. Expect some nostalgia, a little wishful thinking, and maybe even a dash of “if we were in charge” fun 🤔💭
The Commander Smiths talk about the newest Festival in a box announcement that will be on sale August 18. We also have the finals announcement on the best basic land art. the main segment is which expensive cards do we wish could be reprinted to play with more. Enjoy!
 
Wish List of Reprints
Lowery
Mishra's Workshop https://scryfall.com/card/atq/81/mishras-workshop
Moat https://scryfall.com/card/leg/28/moat
Earthcraft https://scryfall.com/card/tmp/222/earthcraft
Metalworker https://scryfall.com/card/uds/135/metalworker
Volrath's Stronghold https://scryfall.com/card/sth/143/volraths-stronghold
Survival of the Fittest https://scryfall.com/card/exo/129/survival-of-the-fittest
Mox Diamond https://scryfall.com/card/sth/138/mox-diamond
Memory Jar https://scryfall.com/card/ulg/129/memory-jar
Copy Artifact https://scryfall.com/card/3ed/53/copy-artifact
Replenish https://scryfall.com/card/uds/15/replenish
Adam
Underground Sea https://scryfall.com/card/3ed/290/underground-sea
The Tabernacle of Pendrell Vale https://scryfall.com/card/leg/307/the-tabernacle-at-pendrell-vale
Forcefield https://scryfall.com/card/2ed/244/forcefield
Gaea's Cradle https://scryfall.com/card/usg/321/gaeas-cradle
Lake of the Dead https://scryfall.com/card/all/140/lake-of-the-dead
Wheel of Fortune https://scryfall.com/card/3ed/185/wheel-of-fortune
Yavimaya Hollow https://scryfall.com/card/uds/143/yavimaya-hollow
Gilded Drake https://scryfall.com/card/usg/76/gilded-drake
Powery Artifact https://scryfall.com/card/atq/11/power-artifact
Serra's Sanctum https://scryfall.com/card/usg/325/serras-sanctum
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/tbHsn910ADM
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🚨 LIVE 🚨 The State of Planeswalkers in Commander... Are They Getting Stronger? #386

Episode 386: 
🎙 This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙
We’re talking about the state of planeswalkers! 🧙‍♂️ Since March of the Machine and the big "fall of planeswalkers," Wizards has scaled back how many we see… but lately the ones we do get are way more powerful. We're breaking down how this shift impacts Commander... the pros, the cons... and if we think planeswalkers are finally in a good spot again.
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/gNb-RNl8wdg
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Best Edge of Eternities Cards for Commander! Our Top 10 Picks & Hot Takes! - #385

Episode 385: 
🎙 This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙
The Commander Smiths have a full plate show today. First we go over the surprise Chaos Vault Secret Lair that popped up today with Crucible of Worlds Galaxy Foil involved. We also go over another round of the Basic Land Tournament. We’re diving into Edge of Eternities with our classic Fav 5-style Top 10! 💥
Each of us is breaking down our Top 5 commanders and Top 5 cards from the set... plus sharing thoughts on new builds, cool synergies, and which cards are gonna make a splash in Commander. Whether you’re brewing with new legends or hunting for the best upgrades... we’ve got you covered. Come hang out, laugh along, and see if your picks line up with ours! 👊🔥
Legends
Adam:
Mm'menon, the Right Hand: https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/68/mmmenon-the-right-hand
Tannuk, Memorial Ensign https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/233/tannuk-memorial-ensign
Dawnsire, Sunstar Dreadnaught https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/238/dawnsire-sunstar-dreadnought
Lowery:
Ragost, https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/224/ragost-deft-gastronaut
Haliya, https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/19/haliya-guided-by-light
Tannuk, https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/162/tannuk-steadfast-second
Sami, https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/226/sami-wildcat-captain
 
Fav5
Adam:
Tez, Cruel Captain https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/2/tezzeret-cruel-captain
Evendo, https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/253/evendo-waking-haven
Ouroboroid https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/201/ouroboroid
Terrasymbiosis https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/210/terrasymbiosis
Weftwalking https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/86/weftwalking
Lowery:
Icetill Explorer https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/192/icetill-explorer
Exalted Sunborn https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/15/exalted-sunborn
Anticausal Vistage https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/1/anticausal-vestige
Umbral Collar Zealot https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/123/umbral-collar-zealot
The Eternity Elevator https://scryfall.com/card/eoe/241/the-eternity-elevator
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/SVl7yL-CjlQ
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Edge of Eternities Precons – Worth It or Not? Full Breakdown & Upgrades - #384

Episode 384: 
🎙 This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙
We’re finally back! After a 3-week break, we're live again and diving into Edge of Eternities! ✨
This week we’re breaking down the two Commander Precon decks from the new set. We’ll go over the reprints, all the spicy new cards, and ask the big question: Are these decks worth the price? 💰
Then, we’ll show you how to pimp them out—both on a budget and with some no-holds-barred upgrades! Whether you're new to Commander or looking to fine-tune these decks into powerhouses, we've got you covered.
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/9O1tgKbyPXw
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game - Episode 1 Vol 1

🎉 Welcome to the FIRST episode of Magic Password! 🤫🔑Think you know Magic: The Gathering? Time to prove it!
Magic Password is our brand-new, fast-paced MTG trivia showdown where teams go head-to-head guessing secret Magic words using only one-word clues. It's chaotic... it's fun... and it’ll put your Magic brain to the test! 🧠💥
 
🚨 LIVE 🚨 Episode Here
https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
 
🔥 How to Play:
Two teams of two
One teammate sees the Magic Password (a single MTG-related word)
The team with the lower score decides who goes first
Players take turns giving one-word clues to help their teammate guess the word
Guess it on the first try? That’s 10 points!
Miss it? The other team steals with a new clue for fewer points (down to 5 max)
No gestures, no gibberish—just real words and a ticking clock!
First team to 80 points WINS! 🏆
💡 Inspired by KFAN’s Password segment here in the Twin Cities... and a huge shoutout to Tad for making the word lists and hosting this thing like a boss 🙌
🎮 Play Along at Home!Can YOU beat the Smiths? Keep score and drop your results in the comments!
❤️ Like what you see? Smash that like button, subscribe for more Magic chaos, and consider joining our Patreon for exclusive Discord access and other sweet perks.
👇 Support the Smith Boys!🛒 MTG merch, Kill Him Tokens & more:👉 Adam's eBay Store
🎉 Join our Patreon for behind-the-scenes fun:👉 Patreon Link
💸 Help us keep the lights on with live donations:👉 Streamlabs Link
📬 Got a question? Stump the Smith Savant card? Just wanna say hey?📧 commandersmiths@gmail.com
🎉 A FREE way to support us is by liking and subscribing right here:👉 Subscribe to the CommanderSmiths!
Let’s see who the REAL MTG mastermind is... LET’S GO! 🔥🎉

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Battle of the Basics! | MTG’s Ultimate Land Showdown + Sonic Secret Lair Reveal - #383

Episode 383: 
🎙 This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙
We’re doing it. The long-awaited Basic Land Tournament is finally here! 💥 16 styles enter... only 1 basic will reign supreme. We’re breaking it all down—voting, arguing, and probably losing friendships over Forests vs. Islands.
PLUS—surprise drop! We got hit with a Sonic the Hedgehog Secret Lair spoiler out of nowhere, and yep… we’ve got thoughts. Gotta go fast... but not before we roast some art and rank some lands. 😂🌍💙
 
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/A-beofrnlRY
 
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️
Come for the finance... stay for the chaos!#MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH