MTG Commander Smiths Podcast

💰💸 Is The Our Boss is on Vacation Superdrop Secret Lair Worth It? 💸💰 - #369

Episode 369: 
🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We're diving into the Secret Lair: Our Boss Is on Vacation Superdrop, dropping Monday, the 24th! This massive release features nine different drops, including the highly anticipated SpongeBob SquarePants collabs and six other unique sets.
Is this Superdrop worth your hard-earned cash? We'll break down Break Points (BP) for each drop, analyze the value, and help you decide whether to go deep, grab a few, or skip it altogether.
 
🚨 LIVE Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/wDSs3HgNW3Q?feature=share
 
 
🔗 What’s in the Drop?Check out the full list here!
🔗 Secret Lair Store:Buy it when it drops!
💸 Financial Breakdown (Before Fees & Shipping):
Legends of Bikini Bottom✨ Foil: $100 (BP 3) 🔥 Non-Foil: $65 (BP 3)
Internet Sensation✨ Foil: $60 (BP 8) 🔥 Non-Foil: $40 (BP None)
Lands Under The Sea✨ Foil: $80-150 (BP 2) 🔥 Non-Foil: $50-100 (BP 2)
Tragic Romance✨ Foil: $85 (BP 3) 🔥 Non-Foil: $60 (BP 3)
Garden Buds✨ Foil: $90 (BP 3) 🔥 Non-Foil: $55 (BP 4)
They Grow Up So Fast: Dragons✨ Foil: $90 (BP 3) 🔥 Non-Foil: $65 (BP 3)
Twisted Toons✨ Foil: $85 (BP 3) 🔥 Non-Foil: $65 (BP 3)
Pick 'Em and Stick 'Em✨ Foil: $75 (BP 3) 🔥 Non-Foil: $50 (BP 5)
Secret Lair High: Class of '87✨ Foil: $40 (BP None) 🔥 Non-Foil: $30 (BP None)
What is Break Point (BP)?
Break Point (BP) tells you how many copies you need to buy before you essentially get one for free after reselling the extras.
How it works:1️⃣ Add up the lowest Foil and Non-Foil values.2️⃣ Subtract fees, shipping, and drop cost to find Net Profit.3️⃣ Divide total profit by the cost of one drop to get your BP.
🔍 Example:
If a drop costs $40 and has a Net Profit of $80, buying 2 covers the cost of one (BP 2).
If Net Profit is $55, you’d need 4 drops to break even (BP 4).
💡 Pro Tip: Prices often dip after shipping but tend to recover or even rise 10-16 months later—patience can pay off!
🔗 Want More Info?
📢 Full breakdown: Magic Secret Lair Winter Superdrop 2025 Announcement🛒 Buy it when it drops: Secret Lair Website
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🔥 Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon🛍️ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens: Adam’s eBay Store💰 Donate Live: Streamlabs
🎉 A FREE way to support us? Subscribe & like the video!👉 Subscribe Here
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
💬 Got Questions?
📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant submissions, questions, or just to chat!
Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today! 🎙️

🚨 LIVE 🚨The Only TUTORS Worth Playing in Commander: Fair Vs. GODLY! - #368

Episode 368: 
🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We're diving into tutors—the fair ones, the best ones, and really, the only ones you should be using! We’re breaking down why theme-related tutors and land tutors are the real MVPs while discussing which ones keep the game fun and interactive.
Are all tutors bad for Commander? Or do some actually make the game better? Let’s settle the debate! 🔍✨
Don't miss out—hit that subscribe button and join the conversation! 💙
Adams tutors:
Sunforger https://scryfall.com/card/cmr/473/sunforger
Defense of the Heart https://scryfall.com/card/ulg/100/defense-of-the-heart
Gamble https://scryfall.com/card/dmr/121/gamble
Opposition Agent https://scryfall.com/card/cmr/141/opposition-agent
Bribery https://scryfall.com/card/cmm/77/bribery
Lowerys tutors:
Urza's Saga https://scryfall.com/card/mh2/259/urzas-saga
Inventor's fair https://scryfall.com/card/kld/247/inventors-fair
Chord of Calling https://scryfall.com/card/rvr/134/chord-of-calling
Sterling grove https://scryfall.com/card/mh2/293/sterling-grove
Goblin Engineer https://scryfall.com/card/mh1/128/goblin-engineer
 
🚨 LIVE Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/vVkw8CsgpQQ
 
🛒 Check Out Our Store!Get your MTG merch, Kill Him Tokens, playmats, and more!👉 Adam's eBay Storehttps://www.ebay.com/str/commandersmithsadam
 
📢 Support the Smith Boys!Join our Patreon and unlock exclusive Discord perks:👉 Patreon Linkhttps://www.patreon.com/commandersmiths
 
💸 Donate Live!Support us during our live streams here:👉 Streamlabs Donation Linkhttps://streamlabs.com/commandersmiths1
 
🎉 A FREE way to support us—subscribe to our YouTube channel and like/share our content!👉 Subscribe Herehttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4mttoLhPuTpOUMsqF1O-og?view_as=subscriber
💬 Get in Touch!📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant cards, questions, or just to chat!
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag

🚨 LIVE 🚨Good vs. Evil: The Only Counterspells Worth Playing in Commander! - #367

Episode 367: Good vs. Evil: The Only Counterspells Worth Playing in Commander!
🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We’re tackling the ultimate blue debate—Good Counterspells vs. Evil Counterspells! Which ones make the game more interactive, and which ones just ruin everyone's day? We’ll break down what makes a counterspell "fair," which ones we’d actually play, and why some belong in the deepest pits of salt.
Love ‘em or hate ‘em, counterspells shape Commander—let’s figure out which ones are worth running! 💙✨
 
🛒 Check Out Our Store!Get your MTG merch, Kill Him Tokens, playmats, and more!👉 Adam's eBay Storehttps://www.ebay.com/str/commandersmithsadam
📢 Support the Smith Boys!Join our Patreon and unlock exclusive Discord perks:👉 Patreon Linkhttps://www.patreon.com/commandersmiths
💸 Donate Live!Support us during our live streams here:👉 Streamlabs Donation Linkhttps://streamlabs.com/commandersmiths1
🎉 A FREE way to support us—subscribe to our YouTube channel and like/share our content!👉 Subscribe Herehttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4mttoLhPuTpOUMsqF1O-og?view_as=subscriber
💬 Get in Touch!📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com for Stump the Smith Savant cards, questions, or just to chat!
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
 
Don't miss out on our weekly podcast, deck techs, and all things MTG Commander. Hit that subscribe button and join the CommanderSmiths family today!

🚨 LIVE 🚨Top 10 WHITE Cards - Core Cards for Commander! - #366

Episode 366: Core Cards for Commander: WHITE Edition!
🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We’re diving into the core white cards every Commander player should have! After covering colorless, green, and blue staples, it's time to break down white’s best tools—from board wipes and protection to recursion and value engines.
We’ll cover must-have removal, game-saving spells, and versatile utility cards that fit into nearly any deck. Whether you're building from scratch or fine-tuning, these white staples will keep you ahead of the game! ⚪
Don’t miss it!
🔥 Key Topics:✔️ Essential white staples for Commander✔️ Removal, protection, and recursion must-haves✔️ Versatile utility cards for any white deck✔️ Why these belong in your Commander toolbox
💬 Join the Discussion!📧 Email us at CommanderSmiths@gmail.com with Stump the Smith Savant cards, questions, or just to chat!
🛒 Support the Smith Boys!👉 Adam's eBay Store – Get MTG merch, Kill Him Tokens, playmats & more!🔗 https://www.ebay.com/str/commandersmithsadam
👉 Patreon – Get exclusive Discord perks & more!🔗 https://www.patreon.com/commandersmiths
💸 Donate Live!🔗 https://streamlabs.com/commandersmiths1
🎥 Recent Videos
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: An MTG Trivia Game 🤫🔗 https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉🔗 https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and share—it’s a free way to support us and helps us grow the channel!

🚨 LIVE 🚨Top 10 BLUE Cards - Core Cards for Commander! - #365

Episode 365: Core Cards for Commander: BLUE Edition!
🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We’re breaking down the essential blue cards every Commander player should have in their toolbox! After covering colorless staples, it’s time to focus on blue’s best spells—from card draw to counterspells, interaction, and control.
We’ll highlight powerful draw engines, game-changing spells, and tricky utility cards that can fit into nearly any deck. Whether you’re building from scratch or refining your list, these blue staples will help you stay ahead of the game! 🔵
Don’t miss it!
🔥 Key Topics:
Must-have blue staples for Commander
Counterspells, card draw, and interaction essentials
Utility cards that work in any blue deck
Why these cards belong in your Commander toolbox
Whether you’re a seasoned player or just starting out, this episode is packed with insights to level up your collection and gameplay!
🛒 Get Your Commander Smith Merch & More!Check out Adam’s eBay store for Kill Him Tokens, playmats, and more!👉 Adam's eBay Store
📢 Support the Smith Boys!Join our Patreon for exclusive Discord perks & monthly proxy rewards:👉 Patreon Link
💸 Donate Live!Help support the channel during our live streams:👉 Streamlabs Donation Link
🎉 The BEST way to support us? It’s FREE!Like, share, and subscribe to our channel—it helps us grow!👉 Subscribe Here
💬 Get in Touch!📧 Send us your Stump the Smith Savant card ideas, questions, or just say hi!Email: CommanderSmiths@gmail.com
🔥 Check Out More CommanderSmiths Content!Stay tuned for weekly podcasts, deck techs, and all things MTG Commander! Hit that subscribe button and join the CommanderSmiths family today!

🚨 LIVE 🚨 Commander Brackets! Is This The Answer For Commander? What Gets Unbanned? - #364

Episode 364: Commander Brackets! 🏆
🎙️ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
We’re breaking down the brand-new Commander Brackets!
🔹 What are they, and where do you land in the rankings?🔹 Should the Rules Committee rethink the system?🔹 What’s the Game Changer List, and how does it impact the format?🔹 Plus, which banned cards might make a comeback? 👀
Join us as we dig into these big updates and how they could shake up Commander! ⚡
👉 Watch now & join the conversation!📺 https://youtube.com/live/efZqWmZGP4s
🔥 Check Out Our Latest Videos! 🔥
🐉 NEW Commander Gameplay: Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander'! 🐉📺 https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
✔️ Secret Lair Winter Superdrop – Worth It? ❄️📺 https://youtube.com/live/7koeZxji-PM?feature=share
💪 Support the CommanderSmiths!
🏪 Merch Store – Now on eBay! 🛍️ 👉 CommanderSmiths eBay Store💸 Patreon – Get exclusive perks & join our Discord! 🔥 👉 Patreon📧 Email Us – Stump the Smith Savant, questions, or just wanna chat?✉️ CommanderSmiths@gmail.com
💙 Free Ways to Help: Like, Share & Subscribe! 🎉

💰💸 Is The Winter Superdrop 2025 Secret Lair Worth It? 💸💰 - #363

Episode 363: EARLY Release Winter Superdrop 2025 Secret Lair... Is It Worth It?
🎙️ This week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙️
Considering the Secret Lair Winter Superdrop 2025? Is it worth the investment?
In this episode, we break down all the details so you can make an informed decision before the drop goes live on Monday, February 10th! We'll analyze the cards, artwork, exclusive bonuses, and the financial value, comparing it to other similar cards to help determine if this one holds up.
💸 Financial Breakdown Before Fees & Shipping:
Hatsune Miku: Winter Diva✨ Foil: $115 (BP 2) 🔥 NonFoil: $85 (BP 2)
Aether Drifters:✨ Foil: $50 🔮 (BP None) 🔥 NonFoil: $43 🔮 (BP None)
Arcade Racers:✨ Foil: $70 🔮 (BP 4) 🔥 NonFoil: $45 🔮 (BP None)
City Styles 2: Dressed to Kill:✨ Foil: $80 🔮 (BP 3) 🔥 NonFoil: $55 🔮 (BP 4)
Featuring Luke Pearson:✨ Foil: $50 🔮 (BP None) 🔥 NonFoil: $35 🔮 (BP None)
Featuring Mitsuhiro Arita:✨ Foil: $55 🔮 (BP None) 🔥 NonFoil: $35 🔮 (BP None)
Artist Series: Jesper Ejsing:✨ Foil: $80 🔮 (BP 3) 🔥 NonFoil: $63 🔮 (BP 3)
Lorwyn Lightboxes:✨ Foil: $40 🔮 (BP None) 🔥 NonFoil: $25 🔮 (BP None)
What is a Break Point (BP)?
Break Point (BP) is a way to figure out how many Secret Lair drops you need to buy for one to be completely free (because we all want at least one for our own collection, right?). Here's how it works:
1️⃣ Add up the value of the cheapest Foil and Non-Foil versions of each card in the drop.2️⃣ Subtract fees, shipping, and the cost of the drop to find your Net Profit.3️⃣ Divide the total profit by the cost of one drop to get your Break Point.
🔍 Example:If a drop costs $40 and has a Net Profit of $80, you only need to buy 2 drops for one to cover the cost of the other. That's a BP 2.
If the Net Profit is $55, you'd need to buy 4 drops (because 3 sales at $55 each would cover the $160 total cost). That makes it a BP 4.
💡 Pro Tip: Prices usually dip right after shipping, but they often recover or even increase after 10-16 months. So patience can pay off!
🔗 Check out the full list here:Magic Secret Lair Winter Superdrop 2025 Announcement
🎁 When it goes live, buy it here:Secret Lair Website
💸 Support the CommanderSmiths
Join our Patreon for exclusive perks: Patreon
Grab awesome merch from our eBay store: Adam's Store
Donate during our live streams: Streamlabs
Everything we do is fan-made, thanks to your support — no sponsors, just the love of Magic! ❤️

🚨 LIVE 🚨 AETHERDRIFT: Top 10 Cards and Commanders! 🔥 - #362

Episode 362: BUDGET Upgrades Aetherdrift Commander Precons: Is It Worth It?
🎙️ This week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙️
We're diving into the brand-new Aetherdrift set with a Top 10 Fav 5-style breakdown! We'll be sharing our favorite commanders and must-have cards from the set, discussing what makes them stand out, and why they deserve a spot in your collection. Don't miss out on our hot takes and top picks! 🔥
 
Legends:
Adams-
Hashaton, https://scryfall.com/card/drc/1/hashaton-scarabs-fist
Nissa, https://scryfall.com/card/drc/13/nissa-worldsoul-speaker
The Speed Demon https://scryfall.com/card/dft/105/the-speed-demon
Mimeoplasm, https://scryfall.com/card/dft/214/mimeoplasm-revered-one
Temmet, https://scryfall.com/card/drc/4/temmet-naktamuns-will
Lowery:
Ketramose, https://scryfall.com/card/dft/209/ketramose-the-new-dawn
loot, https://scryfall.com/card/dft/212/loot-the-pathfinder
Mendicant Core https://scryfall.com/card/dft/213/mendicant-core-guidelight
Vnwxt, https://scryfall.com/card/dft/73/vnwxt-verbose-host
winter, https://scryfall.com/card/dft/228/winter-cursed-rider
fav. 5
Adam:
Radiant Lotus https://scryfall.com/card/dft/240/radiant-lotus
The Aetherspark https://scryfall.com/card/dft/231/the-aetherspark
Renewed Solidarity https://scryfall.com/card/drc/7/renewed-solidarity
Mindspring Merfolk https://scryfall.com/card/dft/51/mindspring-merfolk
Riptide Gearhulk https://scryfall.com/card/dft/219/riptide-gearhulk
Lowery:
Monument to Endurance https://scryfall.com/card/dft/237/monument-to-endurance
Skyserpent Seeker https://scryfall.com/card/dft/224/skyserpent-seeker
Unstoppable Plan https://scryfall.com/card/dft/72/unstoppable-plan
Howlsquad Heavy https://scryfall.com/card/dft/134/howlsquad-heavy
Full Throttle https://scryfall.com/card/dft/127/full-throttle
Don’t miss it!
 
Don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe! 🎉
 
🎥 Watch the episode and join the conversation!👉 https://youtube.com/live/iBsQPFz6bZM
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
NEW COMMANDER GAMEPLAY VIDEO!
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉
https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
 
 
Support the CommanderSmiths
🏪 Merch Store: Now on eBay! 👉 CommanderSmiths eBay Store💸 Patreon: Get exclusive perks and join our Discord 👉 Patreon📧 Email Us: Have a Stump the Smith Savant card, questions, or just want to chat?✉️ CommanderSmiths@gmail.com
Free Ways to Help:
Like, Share & Subscribe on YouTube 👉 YouTube Channel
Check out our recent videos:
💡 Deck Techs, Tips, and Spotlights
Chaos Vault Secret Lair Worth
Proxy Time!
Black Panther Deck Tech
We hope everyone had a happy and safe holiday season! Enjoy the show! 🎉

🚨 LIVE 🚨 BUDGET Upgrades Aetherdrift Commander Precons: Is It Worth It? - #361

Episode 361: BUDGET Upgrades Aetherdrift Commander Precons: Is It Worth It?
🎙️ This week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙️
We’re diving into the new ✨ Aetherdrift Commander Precons!
💰 First, we’ll break down whether these decks are worth it right out of the box by assessing their value.
🛠️ Then we’ll tackle budget-friendly upgrades with a $20 limit to get the most bang for your buck.
🔥 Finally, Mr. Unlimited will go wild with his no-budget, full-throttle upgrades. Don’t miss this deck-building journey from frugal tweaks to all-out power! 💥
Don’t miss it!
 
Don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe! 🎉
 
🎥 Watch the episode and join the conversation!👉 https://youtube.com/live/uA3-BraC2Qw
 
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
NEW COMMANDER GAMEPLAY VIDEO!
🐉 Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander' 🐉
https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
 
 
Support the CommanderSmiths
🏪 Merch Store: Now on eBay! 👉 CommanderSmiths eBay Store💸 Patreon: Get exclusive perks and join our Discord 👉 Patreon📧 Email Us: Have a Stump the Smith Savant card, questions, or just want to chat?✉️ CommanderSmiths@gmail.com
Free Ways to Help:
Like, Share & Subscribe on YouTube 👉 YouTube Channel
Check out our recent videos:
💡 Deck Techs, Tips, and Spotlights
Chaos Vault Secret Lair Worth
Proxy Time!
Black Panther Deck Tech
We hope everyone had a happy and safe holiday season! Enjoy the show! 🎉

🚨 LIVE 🚨Top 10 GREEN Cards - Core Cards for Commander! - #360

Episode 360: Core Cards for Commander: GREEN Edition!
🎙️ This week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast 🎙️
We’re diving into the essential GREEN cards that every Commander player should consider for their toolbox. Following up on our colorless episode, we’re bringing the green staples into focus— the must-haves that bring value, ramp, removal, and recursion.
From ramp spells to powerful finishers and versatile utility cards, we’ll break down what makes these cards great for Commander and why they deserve a spot in your collection. Whether you’re building a new deck or refining an old one, these green core cards will help you outgrow the competition. 🌳
Don’t miss it!
Key Topics:
Essential green staples for CommanderVersatile ramp and removal optionsUtility cards for every green deckWhy these cards should be in your Commander toolbox
Whether you’re a seasoned Commander player or new to the format, this episode is packed with insights to help refine your collection and elevate your game.
Green Core Cards:
Lowery:
BOP
Sylvan Library
Seedborn Muse
Elven Farsight
Doubling Season
Adams:
The Great Henge
Heroic Intervention
Three Visits
Dryad of the Ilysian Grove
Toski,
 
Don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe! 🎉
 
🎥 Watch the episode and join the conversation!👉 https://youtube.com/live/4DZcU1wSCL0
Support the CommanderSmiths
🏪 Merch Store: Now on eBay! 👉 CommanderSmiths eBay Store💸 Patreon: Get exclusive perks and join our Discord 👉 Patreon📧 Email Us: Have a Stump the Smith Savant card, questions, or just want to chat?✉️ CommanderSmiths@gmail.com
Free Ways to Help:
Like, Share & Subscribe on YouTube 👉 YouTube Channel
Check out our recent videos:
💡 Deck Techs, Tips, and Spotlights
Chaos Vault Secret Lair Worth
Proxy Time!
Black Panther Deck Tech
We hope everyone had a happy and safe holiday season! Enjoy the show! 🎉